Driver preferences generally fall between two main categories: one taking full control of the vehicle and the other letting the vehicle do the controlling. It has been a long-standing debate between fans of manual and automatic transmissions that one is superior to the other.
However, the question regarding which is better may not always be easy to answer. Each type of transmission has its distinct advantages as well as limitations. One can be ideal in a given situation but entirely inapplicable in another.
Let’s take the time to familiarize ourselves with the advantages and disadvantages of the two different transmission types before making the final choice.
Manual Transmission: The Pros and Cons
The term “stick shifts” often refers to automobiles having a manual or conventional transmission. The driver switches to different gears as they accelerate or decelerate their car using a gear or “stick” shift. In the vehicle’s center console, you’ll find the shift lever which is connected to the transmission through a linkage.
Using a manual transmission also involves using the clutch pedal, which is positioned to the left of the brake pedal. The clutch mechanism, which is placed between the engine and the transmission, disengages when the clutch pedal is pressed. To change gears, you must press down the clutch pedal with your left foot to stop the transmission from receiving power from the engine.
Advantages of Manual Transmission
If you are a motorist who wants more overall vehicle control, the manual transmission is for you.
Greater Fuel Efficiency
Compared to automatic engines, manual transmission engines are generally simpler, lighter, and consist of more gears. This means that you'll get more gas mileage out of it than you normally would with an automatic transmission. Drivers have reported saving more money on fuel when using manual transmissions.
Requires Little Maintenance
The automatic transmission consists of a lot of electronic intervention, therefore maintaining it can cost you a lot of money in the long run. Cars with manual transmissions usually require far less maintenance, which means lower cost. Keep in mind though that the clutch mechanism is one thing that a manual transmission possesses that an automatic doesn’t and needs to be kept in good condition all the time.
More Vehicle Control
Despite being built to select the ideal gear for the specific circumstance, automatic transmissions frequently err in times of caution, shifting to a gear that wastes engine power. They are also designed to react to situations as they arise, which prevents drivers from intentionally choosing a lower gear for a greater increase in power or anticipating an impending scenario. With a manual transmission, the driver has more control over the automobile.
Fewer Chances of Being Stolen
There is a growing number of drivers who have no idea how to operate a manual transmission vehicle as automatic transmissions increasingly dominate the roads. There’s a strong possibility therefore that just having a stick shift will be enough to dissuade a car thief from stealing your vehicle because they just know how to drive a manual.
Disadvantages of Manual Transmission
This type of transmission requires more understanding of its mechanism and demands more effort when it comes to the shifting of gears.
Driving Discomfort in Heavy Traffic
When driving in congested traffic, constantly having to step on the clutch to shift from neutral to first gear could get uncomfortable and tiring since your leg muscles rarely have a chance to rest. This may also cause irritability and anxiety, so you need to be patient enough while staying focused.
Needs More Coordination
From properly timing a shift to knowing when to step on the clutch pedal, learning how to drive a vehicle with a manual transmission needs more mind and body coordination. This is especially true in stop-and-go traffic on a steep incline where you need to time the release of the clutch pedal with the press of the gas pedal so that your car won’t roll back and possibly hit the vehicle immediately behind you. Since you must do the controlling all by yourself, it may take more time to master.
Automatic Transmission: The Pros and Cons
In contrast to a manual transmission, where the driver actively participates in shifting the gears of the vehicle depending on the situation, an automatic transmission only needs the driver to select D (as in drive) on the shifter. The car autonomously completes gear shifts on its own using fluid pressure. The planetary gear set is considered as the automatic transmission's brains. The various gear ratios that the transmission uses are produced by this component.
Automatic transmission fluid provides the pressure required to engage the bands and clutches that determine what gear the car should be in. This fluid contributes to acceleration in addition to cooling and lubricating the transmission's working parts.
Advantages of Automatic Transmission
The hard work is done for you by an automatic gearbox, which uses a torque converter. Only moving forward, moving backward, or stopping is when the driver needs to choose the right setting.
Provides Smoother Rides
Many people choose automatic vehicles because they are convenient and easy to drive as there is no clutch to worry about (in manual transmission, your car can stall if you release the clutch prematurely). Automatic gearboxes provide a smooth change between ratios, giving you a smooth ride.
Perfect for Driving in Heavy Traffic
As the automatic transmission mainly handles the shifting for you, it is more convenient to drive. You don’t have to worry about accidentally missing the clutch pedal or timing a shift and stopping your engine.
Easier Navigation
When you’re driving with a manual transmission, you could find it challenging to maneuver your vehicle, especially on steep inclines. This problem is solved by an automatic gearbox, which allows your car to effectively run no matter how steep the hill may be.
Less Risk of Stalling
Stalling your car by accident just as the traffic light changes is one of the most uncomfortable and awkward things that may happen with manual transmission. For automatic transmission, this doesn’t happen unless there is an issue with the vehicle.
Disadvantages of Automatic Transmission
Some people believe that driving is less enjoyable if they are using an automatic. They get satisfaction from the sensation of shifting gears and having a stronger physical connection with their car.
Expensive Maintenance
Since automatic gearboxes consist of many moving components, they relatively require more time to fix, which increases the overall cost. Also, when it comes to insurance, cars with automatic transmissions can be more expensive since the gearboxes cost more to replace.
Difficulty When Switching to Manual Driving
If you have already mastered driving a vehicle with a manual transmission, it would be easy for you to learn how to drive an automatic. However, when it’s the other way around, drivers who are used to automatic transmissions would most likely find it hard to control vehicles with manual transmissions.
Final Thoughts
It ultimately comes down to your preferences and the areas where you anticipate doing the most of your driving. If convenience is your top priority, the best transmission for you is automatic. It will also work wonders for you if you find yourself driving more in the city. On the other hand, if you prefer a little bit more control over your driving, a manual transmission is what you should go for.
Generally speaking, an automatic transmission is more user-friendly and comfortable for the driver, while manual cars are more economical and provide overall control.
Stay up to date on all things automobile and embark on the future of mobility with DOON, your fully insured peer-to-peer car-sharing marketplace in the Philippines. Whether you're seeking a reliable ride or aiming to earn extra income by sharing your idle car, DOON facilitates a seamless and secure car-sharing experience.
Explore the possibilities by downloading the DOON app, available on the App Store, Google Play Store, or App Gallery. Stay connected through our social media channels — follow DOON on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, LinkedIn, and YouTube.
Ready to redefine your journey? Join DOON today and embrace a smarter way to drive or earn!
For further inquiries as well as partnerships, you can shoot us an email at hello@doon.ph!
Comments